In principle, tax loss carry-forwards can be utilized indefinitely. However, tax loss carry forwards are disallowed according to the Austrian loss trafficking rules if the identity of the corporate taxpayer changes pursuant to a significant change of the organizational, economic and shareholder structure. All three requirements must cumulatively be fulfilled in order that tax loss carry- forwards are disallowed. However, the three criteria do not need to be fulfilled to an equal extent, e.g. if two criteria are very clearly fulfilled and the third one a little, the Austrian loss trafficking rules may still apply.
In a recent decision the Austrian Administrative Supreme Court was confronted with a case where the previous 100%-shareholder (and managing director) of a company sold 55% of the shares and the business of the company was changed from real estate development to real estate brokerage. Even though the company still did its business in the real estate industry, the court qualified the transition from development to brokerage as a change of the economic structure. Furthermore, since in the case at hand the shareholder actually had the ability to influence the economic and organizational direction of the company, a “not insignificant” shareholder amounting to 55% was deemed as enough to be viewed as a significant change for the purposes of the loss trafficking rules. This is in contrast to the predominant opinion in Austrian tax practice that only shareholder changes amounting to at least 75% are viewed as relevant.
Therefore, the Austrian Administrative Supreme Court overturned that Austrian Federal Finance Court’s decision and ruled that the loss trafficking rules apply in the case at hand.
M. Vaishor / A. Lunzer