The proposed tax concessionary regime for physical commodity trading business in Hong Kong represents another step taken by the HKSAR Government toward extending Hong Kong’s tax incentives to sectors beyond financial services.
Currently, Singapore also offers a tax incentive for commodity trading businesses in Singapore under the Global Trader Programme7 (GTP). The GTP applies to a wide range of commodity trading activities (including physical trading, derivative trading and structured commodity financing activities) and offers a preferential tax rate as low as 5%. While there are differences in the scope and tax rate offered under the Hong Kong and Singapore regimes, taxpayers should be mindful that the qualifying requirements, the degree of certainty and compliance burden may also be different under the two regimes.
To ensure the proposed tax concessionary regime in Hong Kong serves its policy objective, the government needs to continuously monitor its usage, solicit feedback from the industry and consider making any necessary enhancements. Although the major policy objective of the proposed concession is to bolster the development of the maritime services sector and therefore the current scope of the concession only covers physical commodity trading, we urge the government to consider, as the next step, expanding the scope of the concession to cover derivative trading and other financing activities related to commodity trading to nurture a more sustainable development of the commodity trading ecosystem in Hong Kong.
In addition, to strengthen the overall competitiveness of Hong Kong’s tax system as a whole, we recommend that the government looks into the other aspects of the Hong Kong tax system where refinements may be warranted. An example is the existing stringent interest expense deduction rules in Hong Kong which may pose challenges for overseas business groups seeking to conduct their businesses in Hong Kong.