Further details
Article 15 of the OECD Model Tax Convention addresses the attribution of taxing rights between two Contracting States in respect of Employment Income. The interpretation of the term “derived by a resident of a contracting state” in Article 15(1) of the OECD model treaty is central to the question of how a treaty should be applied to deferred remuneration.
In practice, the question has been whether, when determining the attribution of taxing rights over deferred remuneration between two contracting states, it is correct to look at:
- The individual’s treaty residence position at the time of payment; or
- The individual’s treaty residence throughout the performance period of an award, which may vary.
HMRC’s new guidance confirms that it is the individual’s treaty residence position at the point of payment that drives the reading of Article 15(1) and the subsequent attribution of taxing rights. This is a welcome clarification that may provide the catalyst for resolving open enquiries on this topic.
However, it is important to remember that not all treaties follow the wording of the OECD Model, so it is important to always check the wording of the applicable treaty when assessing its application.
The guidance confirms that deferred remuneration payments received by individuals will be treated as follows, under UK domestic law and the double tax treaty:
Individual is treaty resident in the UK at payment:
- Under UK domestic law, the UK would tax the portion that relates to UK workdays in the portion of the payment that relates to the period of non-residence, and the full portion of the payment that relates to the period of residence.
- Under the double tax treaty, as the UK is the state of the individual’s residence, the UK would have the right to tax the full payment under the treaty. However, the UK would not exercise this right to tax amounts that would not otherwise be taxable under UK domestic law, and HMRC acknowledge that there could be scenarios where a portion of a payment is not taxable in any state due to the domestic law and tax treaty interaction.
Individual is treaty non-resident in the UK at payment:
- Under UK domestic law, the UK would tax the portion that relates to UK workdays in the portion of the payment that relates to the period of non-residence, and the full portion of the payment that relates to the period of residence.
- However, under the tax treaty, as the “State of Source,” the UK would only have the right to tax the portion that relates to UK workdays throughout the whole of the performance period, regardless of where the individual was resident.